A comprehensive framework for the rapid prototyping of ubiquitous interaction

Resumen

In the interaction between humans and computational systems, many advances have been made in terms of hardware (e.g., smart devices with embedded sensors and multi-touch surfaces) and software (e.g., algorithms for the detection and tracking of touches, gestures and full body movements). Now that we have the computational power and devices to manage interactions between the physical and the digital world, the question is—what should we do? For the Human-Computer Interaction research community answering to this question means to materialize Mark Weiser’s vision of Ubiquitous Computing. In the desktop computing paradigm, the desktop metaphor is implemented by a graphical user interface operated via mouse and keyboard. Users are accustomed to employing artificial control devices whose operation has to be learned and they interact in an environment that inhibits their faculties. For example the mouse is a device that allows movements in a two dimensional space, thus limiting the twenty three degrees of freedom of the human’s hand. The Ubiquitous Computing is an evolution in the history of computation: it aims at making the interface disappear and integrating the information processing into everyday objects with computational capabilities. In this way humans would no more be forced to adapt to machines but, instead, the technology will harmonize with the surrounding environment. Conversely from the desktop case, ubiquitous systems make use of heterogeneous Input/Output devices (e.g., motion sensors, cameras and touch surfaces among others) and interaction techniques such as touchless, multi-touch, and tangible. By reducing the physical constraints in interaction, ubiquitous technologies can enable interfaces that endow more expressive power (e.g., free-hand gestures) and, therefore, such technologies are expected to provide users with better tools to think, create and communicate. It appears clear that approaches based on classical user interfaces from the desktop computing world do not fit with ubiquitous needs, for they were thought for a single user who is interacting with a single computing systems, seated at his workstation and looking at a vertical screen. To overcome the inadequacy of the existing paradigm, new models started to be developed that enable users to employ their skills effortlessly and lower the cognitive burden of interaction with computational machines. Ubiquitous interfaces are pervasive and thus invisible to its users, or they become invisible with successive interactions in which the users feel they are instantly and continuously successful. All the benefits advocated by ubiquitous interaction, like the invisible interface and a more natural interaction, come at a price: the design and development of interactive systems raise new conceptual and practical challenges. Ubiquitous systems communicate with the real world by means of sensors, emitters and actuators. Sensors convert real world inputs into digital data, while emitters and actuators are mostly used to provide digital or physical feedback (e.g., a speaker emitting sounds). Employing such variety of hardware devices in a real application can be difficult because their use requires knowledge of underneath physics and many hours of programming work. Furthermore, data integration can be cumbersome, for any device vendor uses different programming interfaces and communication protocols. All these factors make the rapid prototyping of ubiquitous systems a challenging task. Prototyping is a pivoting activity to foster innovation and creativity through the exploration of a design space. Nevertheless, while there are many prototyping tools and guidelines for traditional user interfaces, very few solutions have been developed for a holistic prototyping of ubiquitous systems. The tremendous amount of different input devices, interaction techniques and physical environments envisioned by researchers produces a severe challenge from the point of view of general and comprehensive development tools. All of this makes it difficult to work in a design and development space where practitioners need to be familiar with different related subjects, involving software and hardware. Moreover, the technological context is further complicated by the fact that many of the ubiquitous technologies have recently grown from an embryonic stage and are still in a process of maturation; thus they lack of stability, reliability and homogeneity. For these reasons, it is compelling to develop tools support to the programming of ubiquitous interaction. In this thesis work this particular topic is addressed. The goal is to develop a general conceptual and software framework that makes use of hardware abstraction to lighten the prototyping process in the design of ubiquitous systems. The thesis is that, by abstracting from low-level details, it is possible to provide unified, coherent and consistent access to interacting devices independently of their implementation or communication protocols. In this dissertation the existing literature is revised and is pointed out that there is a need in the art of frameworks that provide such a comprehensive and integrate support. Moreover, the objectives and the methodology to fulfill them, together with the major contributions of this work are described. Finally, the design of the proposed framework, its development in the form of a set of software libraries, its evaluation with real users and a use case are presented. Through the evaluation and the use case it has been demonstrated that by encompassing heterogeneous devices into a unique design it is possible to reduce user efforts to develop interaction in ubiquitous environments. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------